Talk:Vulcan nerve pinch
From Memory Alpha, the free Star Trek reference
Contents |
[edit] Effects on a Human?
Didn't the Docotr explain the effects of the vulcan nerve pinch on a human in that episode where Chakotay is seperated from his body and uses Tuvok to aply the pinch? Although he didn't know it was a Vulcan nerve pinch, but I think it is safe to assume that those effects came from nothing else. -- Redge 12:41, 17 Jun 2004 (CEST)
Odo used what appeared to be the Vulcan nerve pinch in "Babel" against Quark's dissatisfied customer, but it only hurt the guy-- it didn't knock him out. Anyone care to verify that it was, in fact, the nerve pinch and not something else? Ekedolphin 04:33, 13 Sep 2005 (UTC)
I believe it is speculation that Captain Picard learned the Vulcan Nerve Pinch via mind-meld since he slugged a Romulan when Spock and Data used the pinch, (TNG "Unification) which was two years after he mind-melded Sarek (TNG "Sarek"). SkyStreak 10:25, 8 Sep 2006 (EST)
[edit] Pistol whipping or phaser blast?
Was Spock too dignified to render someone unconscious by hitting them with a phaser blast or too dignified to render someone unconscious by "pistol-whipping" them with a phaser? This sentence was recently changed, but since neither mentions had a reference, can someone provide a source for either statement? -Humuhumunukunukuāpuaʻa 20:05, 10 January 2007 (UTC)
From "I Am Spock", chapter 4:
"[...]In one particular scene, this "evil" character had confronted the "good" Kirk and was about to destroy him with a phaser blast. The original script called for Spock to steal up behind the "bad" Kirk and strike him over the head with the butt of a phaser." 69.47.223.96 05:35, 1 March 2007 (UTC)
I changed the sentence to "striking them over the head with the butt of a phaser" and removed the {{pna-inaccurate}} message. Little Fuzzy Cygnet 18:20, 3 March 2007 (UTC)
[edit] Nerve pinch was invented earlier
Hello!
The nerve pinch was already invented as early as in the second pilot film for the old series "Where no man has gone before".
In this episode Spock clearly tries to do it to Lt. Gary Mitchell, but doesn't succeed to apply it because of Gary's newly acquired superhuman strength.
Best regards
Harald (h.krause4244@t-online.de)
- Actually, while it may have appeared that Spock was attempting to use the nerve pinch in that episode, there have been various sources (including Nimoy himself) stating that the nerve pinch was first devised for the episode "The Enemy Within". The attempted neck pinch in "Where No Man Has Gone Before" (if that is indeed what it was) was likely just a random placement of the hands in an attempt to restrain Mitchell. --From Andoria with Love 21:21, 31 March 2007 (UTC)
No. I have seen this episode over and over again. Spock clearly tries to apply this pinch to Gary - who is just a bit quicker and manages to repulse his adversary by discharging some kind of flash on him.
Best regards
Harald
- For the record, while it may seem that Spock tried to use a nerve pinch in WNMHGB, the fact remains that the technique was not created until "The Enemy Within". Therefore, no, the nerve pinch was not seen in WNMHGB. ;) --From Andoria with Love 22:33, 31 May 2007 (UTC)
[edit] Space Seed
It looks to me like Khan performs something akin to a nerve pinch on a Redshirt as he enters the transporter room. I'm no expert, but perhaps there should be a comment about this on the page? -<unsigned>
Just watched the remastered edition. Yes, he uses his fingertips on both hands at the sides of the neck of the transporter operator, the reaction was the same as a nerve pinch. The crewman wore a blue jumpsuit though. It is never revealed if the crewman died or not. MikeyChalupa 16:23, 25 November 2007 (UTC)
[edit] Seven Did the Nerve Pinch?
Exqueeze me?? Hold the phone, bubba, but where in "The Raven" was she seen doing this? I have not seen the episode but once, long ago> Please tell me where in the episode it was that I may know!
– Watching... listening... 22:07, 30 October 2007 (UTC)
- When Tuvok beams aboard her shuttle, she nerve pinches him. --Jörg 14:27, 31 October 2007 (UTC)
If you look at the third sentence in the background section, it is said that Odo and Data are humans who used a Vulcan nerve pinch. The former is a shapeshifter and the latter is an android. I suggest that the word 'human' in this sentence be changed to 'non-Vulcan' or something like that.
- Fixed. :-)– Cleanse 22:57, 22 March 2008 (UTC)
[edit] I Have Tried...
I strongly disagree with the following conclusion:
- In principle, it was possible to teach the Vulcan nerve pinch to a Human, if that Human manifested the proper aptitudes of concentration.
which the article draws merely from Spock's line in "The Omega Glory":
- On planet Omega IV, while fighting Cloud William and Sirah in his cell, Kirk expressed his appreciation for the neutralization of Sirah by Spock with the pinch, whispering: "You should teach me that some time." Spock answered patiently: "I have tried." (TOS: "The Omega Glory")
How does Spock's line state that it is possible to teach it to a Human? All it states is that he couldn't teach Kirk. It is equally likely that no human yet had learned the pinch, but that Spock tried to teach Kirk anyway as an experiment or because they had nothing better to do. And in any case, where are we getting the "proper aptitudes of concentration" from? From "The Omega Glory" we should just note that Spock had tried and failed to teach Kirk. Anything else is an assumption.– Cleanse 11:30, 26 June 2008 (UTC)